1. If you didn’t vote, you can’t complain. I’ve heard this one a lot. The idea is that voting equals participation in the political process and entitles you to comment on political behavior. This view overlooks the fact that not voting is a political statement in itself. Yes, sometimes the statement is, “I’m lazy,” but other times it means something else. I’ve said before on this blog that I don’t think libertarians are required to abstain from voting, but I certainly understand why some do.
2. If the person you voted for does something, you can’t complain (or it’s your fault). This view promotes an unhealthy view of the political process. It assumes that politics is a dichotomy and if one candidate doesn’t represent my views at all, the other one must be pretty close. Therefore, I’ll vote for that candidate. Since he/she represents my views, I can’t complain. The problem: I may vote for the lesser of two very evil candidates. In fact, I did that in 2004.
3. Both parties (D and R) are exactly the same. Yes, the system offers only a sliver of the political possibilities. Furthermore, American politics operates in a fairly narrow spectrum in terms of world politics. However, within that spectrum, it is clear that members of different parties do tend to support different policies. This may be only because they are trying to win votes, but nonetheless, they are at least mildly different.
4. Both parties are completely different. It wouldn’t be a good political post if I didn’t talk out of both sides of my mouth. I addressed this a bit above, but I’ll expand. I am SO SICK of hardcore party activists. The parties are different, but not THAT different. We don’t have many communists or anarcho-capitalists running for office these days. That said, I usually know which party I’ll vote for when I go into a ballot box (yes, Bama, still pretty much straight ticket). It’s just that the margin between the party I vote for and the other one is not as wide as the DC political hacks want us to believe.
I’m sure I’ll run across more. Maybe enough for a regular post.